Abstract
Some policymakers and advocates view public school choice as a strategy to overcome underlying problems with the U.S. educational system that stem from the tie between racial residential segregation and assigned neighborhood schools. Yet, states and local school districts have adopted diverse school choice policies and programs that may or may not accomplish this objective. In this study we use a two-step floating catchment area method to examine metropolitan-level variation in the relationship between neighborhood racial-ethnic composition—specifically the percentage of Black and Latino/a students—and spatial accessibility to public choice elementary schools. The analysis focuses on the eight largest metropolitan areas in California. The statewide model shows that, all else equal, public choice school access is higher in California neighborhoods with larger shares of Black residents and lower in neighborhoods with larger shares of Latino/a residents. However, these relationships vary across specific metropolitan areas. For example, although the racial-ethnic composition of neighborhoods is not associated with school choice access in the San José and Bakersfield metropolitan areas, the percentage of Black and Latino/a residents is positively associated with school choice access in the San Diego area. If school districts adopt school choice programs, these findings suggest the importance of implementing policies and services to ensure equitable access to them.
