Icon for misc.

website

StoryMap: Hiding Prejudice behind Parking

Publication Date

September 28, 2026

Author(s)

Abstract

Building a mosque requires careful planning to comply with zoning laws and manage community sentiment. Consider the Islamic Society of Santa Barbara (ISSB), the first mosque in this coastal California region. It took ISSB nearly 19 years to open after they purchased property in a rural part of the county. Why 19 years? A combination of city planning obstacles created the delay. First, the establishment of the town of Goleta in 2002 required ISSB to pull its original permit from Santa Barbara County and transfer it to Goleta, which, as a newly incorporated city, still lacked a functioning planning commission. Later, Goleta lost key staff members, delaying the project by three years. Most significantly, ISSB faced overwhelming opposition across 16 public hearings spanning nearly seven more years. Opponents at these hearings raised concerns about many issues, including the mosque’s design, the building’s potential impact on bird flight, and, most notably, where people who come to pray will park their cars. ISSB is not alone. According to the Institute for Social Policy and Understanding (ISPU), opposition to mosques is at an all-time high. In this context, it can be easy to focus on overt discrimination and zoning disputes. But it is just as important to show how benign and overlooked technical requirements – like parking – can become a cudgel to stop Muslim Americans from building places to gather and pray.

Icon for peer review journal article preprint

published journal article

Transportation Labor Challenges for Gig Drivers

Abstract

Given the dynamic landscape surrounding the classification of workers in California, it is important to consider how the existing legal and regulatory environment may impact app-based gig drivers, including transportation network companies (TNCs, also known as ridehailing) and courier network services (CNS). Using a multi-method approach, we conducted a literature review (n = 41 sources), expert interviews (n = 8), and case study analysis (n = 7) between October 2022 to May 2024 to better understand how California’s gig drivers are impacted by state legislation and regulation (i.e., Assembly Bill 5, Proposition 22, and Senate Bill 1014). The expert interviews found that gig drivers are concerned with fair pay, benefits, labor classification, and transparency from the app-based platforms on issues related to punitive actions (i.e., deactivations). Drivers also raised concerns about California’s Clean Miles Standard (also known as SB 1014), which requires 90 % of vehicle miles traveled be electric by 2030, due to the financial costs associated with acquiring and operating electric vehicles (EVs) and limited public charging availability. The seven case studies examine gig labor policies from other states and countries (e.g., policies that may help enhance driver working conditions, platform regulation, and facilitate the EV transition). Together, these methods explore the tension between sustaining an app-based gig driving platform and providing fair compensation and working conditions for gig drivers. The study finds that state and/or local policies establishing minimum pay for drivers and policies enhancing transparency and appeal processes for driver deactivations could help improve working conditions for gig drivers. Various state agencies, such as the California Public Utilities Commission, could support gig drivers through incentives for the purchase of EVs and installation of EV charging near their homes and driving locations.

Icon for peer review journal article preprint

published journal article

The Religion of Parking: How Land Use Planning Enables Anti-Muslim Prejudice

Publication Date

September 18, 2026

Author(s)

Abstract

In this article the research team considers a neglected injustice of parking policy: religious intolerance. Through qualitative interviews and a review of public hearing transcripts and official records, the research shows how residents and officials across the country use parking concerns to mask anti-Muslim prejudice and fight the construction of mosques. The team has isolated the role of religious discrimination quantitatively through a paired comparison of mosques and churches, finding newly proposed mosques are 16% to 18% more likely to experience opposition than newly proposed churches nearby. Further, in contrast to the mosques, parking concerns with the churches never made local news. By comparing parking ratios, the research team also demonstrates both mosques and churches typically provided more parking than codes required. These findings from the team’s mixed-methods study expand the transportation equity agenda to include religion and create space for planners to rethink how intolerance enters planning practice. Takeaway for practice: Planners should consider how zoning provisions that allow for regulatory discretion, such as parking requirements, open up avenues for prejudice. Although planners can shut down or disregard openly discriminatory comments at public hearings, it is hard for them to assess whether concerns over parking—and, by extension, other technical issues such as traffic and water—are genuine or are masks for underlying animus. Although federal laws like the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) protect religious institutions from discrimination, mosque proponents and their attorneys are often reluctant to file lawsuits, particularly against agencies with discretionary authority, due to fear of costs and delays, or simply a desire to be friendly neighbors. Countering prejudice in land use planning therefore calls for removing procedural obstacles to development, giving city staff the authority to handle more permitting decisions ministerially, and eliminating parking requirements altogether.

Icon of megaphone

policy brief

Parking Policy Provides a Pretext for Anti-Muslim Discrimination

Publication Date

September 23, 2026

Author(s)

Abstract

Building a mosque in the US gives rise to opposition. Sometimes, opponents overtly depict Muslims as foreigners threatening American values. In other cases, new mosques are stalled for years or stopped altogether because of concerns about parking: Local officials and residents demand that mosques build more spaces, conduct additional costly parking studies, or attend further public hearings about parking.
Mosques are far from the only type of proposed development to face parking-related opposition. This study isolated the role of religious prejudice by analyzing the opposition faced by 107 newly constructed American mosques, comparing each one to a nearby church built around the same time. Public records of city council hearings were examined and representatives from a sample of the mosques were invited to share their experiences on whether or how parking came up and the impacts of parking-related opposition.

Icon for peer review journal article preprint

published journal article

Examining Racial/Ethnic and Socioeconomic Disparities in Access to California’s Electric Vehicle Charging Infrastructure

Abstract

Equitable access to electric vehicle charging infrastructure is critical to ensuring a rapid, widespread, and inclusive transition to clean transportation. Here, this team evaluates disparities in electric vehicle charging access across California by race, ethnicity, income, housing status, and environmental vulnerability. They uses spatially granular synthetic population data and develop competition-adjusted access metrics for Level 2 and direct current fast chargers using isochrone analysis. They show clear disparities: Black and Hispanic Californians, especially those in majority Black and Hispanic (respectively) neighborhoods, have significantly lower access to charging than white residents. These gaps are wider in dense urban areas and among renters and people living in multifamily housing. Achieving a just transition requires that public and private investment in charging infrastructure account for racial/ethnic and housing equity. Robust analytic methods are therefore essential for effective planning and policy design.

Icon for report

white paper

California and USA Pricing Strategy Experiences

Publication Date

August 26, 2026

Author(s)

Emma Huang, Erin Barry, Joshua Schank, Egon Terplan

Abstract

This white paper examines the successes and failures of road pricing strategies in California and the United States, with implications for congestion pricing across California. It evaluates nine case studies spanning feasibility studies, operational HOT lane programs, and the country’s first large-scale cordon pricing zone. The research team addresses the conditions that favor pricing, barriers, outcomes, and how costs and benefits are distributed using case studies in Los Angeles, San Diego, San Francisco, San Mateo County, Alameda County, New York City, and Northern Virginia. The research finds that successful pricing programs have sustained political champions, state enabling legislation, and benefits visible to identifiable users. Revenue allocation, not toll structure, is the primary determinant of whether pricing is regressive or progressive. No pricing program reviewed was repealed after implementation. The research team concludes that advancing road pricing in California will require clear state leadership and supportive coalitions.

Icon for report

white paper

Equity and Road Pricing: Fairness and Affordability

Abstract

This white paper reconsiders the equity of road pricing by distinguishing between fairness and affordability—two concepts that are otherwise often conflated. A fair price assigns costs in proportion to the burdens a user imposes on others; an affordable price is one that users can pay without hardship. While both are important, these are distinct objectives, and treating them as interchangeable can obscure judgments about whether pricing is morally or ethically correct. Applying this framework suggests congestion pricing is more equitable than flat VMT charges because it better aligns payments with the social costs of driving. While congestion pricing may raise affordability concerns for some users, these concerns can be addressed through targeted redistribution of toll revenues. By contrast, unpriced roads and poorly targeted charges allow drivers to impose substantial external costs on others, undermining fairness even as they appear more affordable.

Icon of megaphone

policy brief

A Systems Approach Can Lower Costs and Protect the Grid as Freight Electrifies

Abstract

California is transitioning heavy-duty freight trucks from diesel to battery-electric vehicles to help meet its climate and air quality goals. Unlike passenger vehicles, electric trucks require much larger batteries and high-powered chargers, creating concentrated demands on the electric grid. At the same time, freight carriers operate under strict schedules that leave little flexibility in when and how long trucks can charge. As freight electrification expands, coordinating truck operations, charging infrastructure, and grid planning will become increasingly important.
Without that coordination, simultaneous truck charging, particularly during periods of high electricity demand, can increase electricity costs, strain local grid infrastructure, and create congestion at charging stations. These challenges are compounded by state and regional incentives that may unintentionally encourage trucks with the largest batteries and fastest chargers rather than the most efficient charging strategies. The result is a more expensive freight electrification system for fleets, utilities, infrastructure providers, and ultimately taxpayers.
To identify strategies that support both efficient freight operations and a reliable electric grid, a grid-aware optimization model using 3.9 million real-world California truck loads was developed. This brief covers how battery size, charger speed, charging schedules, and charger locations affect both fleet operating costs and grid performance.

Icon for peer review journal article preprint

published journal article

Assessing the Complementarity of Microtransit and Public Transit for Sustainable Mobility: Evidence from Three California Cities

Abstract

Microtransit services fill gaps within public transportation systems across the United States (U.S.), but there are questions about whether they complement and compete with fixed-route services. The successful integration of microtransit is important for sustainability because it has the potential to improve the ridership and viability of public transit, which has implications for reducing emissions and increasing vehicle occupancy. Moreover, microtransit may serve as a more cost-effective way to provide transit service in low-density regions, relative to fixed-route services. The research team analyzed survey and trip activity data from three microtransit operations in California, including the Silicon Valley Hopper (N = 457), Richmond Moves (N = 131), and the Via West Sac (N = 224). For the Bay Area systems, surveys were deployed in November 2024, while activity data spanned June 2022 to November 2024. Via West Sac is one of the oldest microtransit systems in the U.S., and data from a May 2019 survey was integrated into the analysis. The survey showed that 35% of Richmond Moves, 31% of Silicon Valley Hopper, and 17% of Via West Sac respondents connected to and/or from public transit during their most recent microtransit trip. It is estimated travel and wait times were lower on microtransit than public transit for 53% of Richmond Moves, 83% of Silicon Valley Hopper, and 85% of Via West Sac trips. The research team also found that 27% of Richmond Moves, 37% of Silicon Valley Hopper, and 52% of Via West Sac trips had no viable fixed-route transit alternative. Insights from these findings and expert interviews were used to define planning and design recommendations to improve complementarity. Key recommendations include providing comparative travel time information between microtransit and public transit options, highlighting faster fixed-route alternatives to requested trips, and offering transfer credits for microtransit trips that connect to transit.

Icon of report

research report

Data Collection Plan for Evaluating the Greenhouse Gas Impacts of High-Occupancy Toll Lane Projects

Abstract

This report presents a data collection plan for evaluating the greenhouse gas (GHG) impacts of high-occupancy toll (HOT) lane projects implemented under Caltrans’ Carbon Reduction Strategy. Because HOT lanes can affect route choice, departure time, vehicle occupancy, and destination choice beyond the managed lane corridor, the report recommends evaluating impacts across the regional travel shed. The research team recommend two approaches for reliable before-and-after estimates of vehicle miles traveled (VMT) by speed bin. The household-based survey approach uses OBD-II, GPS, or smartphone-based tools to observe a representative sample of households within the travel shed, yielding the most detailed evidence on regional VMT and how impacts vary across the population. The infrastructure-based approach combines continuous freeway sensor data with sampled counts and speeds on arterials, local roads, and ramps; it is less costly and easier to implement but offers less insight into the travelers behind observed changes. For each approach, the report describes what data to collect, where and when to collect it, and how to validate and integrate it with EMFAC. The report also includes order-of-magnitude cost estimates for the two alternatives.